Guide
How Data Brokers Get Your Information
Last updated
Data brokers rarely get your information from you. They collect it from government records such as property and voter files, from businesses you deal with, from apps that pass on location and device data, and above all from each other. Each source may hold only a few details, but put together they make a detailed profile of your life.[1]
What is a data broker?
California law defines a data broker as "a business that knowingly collects and sells to third parties the personal information of a consumer with whom the business does not have a direct relationship." California's privacy agency puts it more simply: a business "that gathers and sells consumer information that the consumer didn't give them directly."[2][3]
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) studied nine large data brokers in 2014. It found that "none of the nine data brokers collect data directly from consumers," and grouped their products into three kinds: marketing, risk mitigation (such as identity checks and fraud detection) and people search.[1]
Which public records do data brokers use?
Government records are the foundation. The FTC listed these sources:[1]
- Federal: Census Bureau demographics by city block, the Social Security Administration's Death Master File, the U.S. Postal Service's "address standardization and change of address information," and bankruptcy records from federal courts.
- State and local: real property and assessor records (deeds, mortgages, liens and the owner's identifying information), voter registration ("name, address, date of birth, and party affiliation"), professional and hunting or fishing licenses, motor vehicle records, and court records, including criminal, civil, birth, marriage, divorce and death records.
Not every broker visits a records office. The FTC found that some buy these records from other brokers that "hire people to visit local offices" or have online access, and the nine brokers named "nearly twenty-five" such suppliers.[1]
Some uses are restricted. In 2014 the FTC counted "at least twenty-two states" that prohibit using voter registration records for commercial or non-election purposes, and the federal Driver's Privacy Protection Act limits how motor vehicle records can be disclosed.[1]
Public records also sit largely outside state privacy laws.[4][11] What counts as public information explains what that means for a deletion request.
Do stores and loyalty programs pass on what I buy?
Some of them do. The FTC found that brokers obtain "detailed, transaction-specific data about purchases from retailers and catalog companies," including what was bought, the amount, the date and the type of payment. Brokers also got magazine subscription data, customer lists from sites where people register to shop, read news or book travel, and aggregated transaction data from financial companies.[1]
Most of this commercial data came through other brokers. One supplier the FTC described models "the purchase history of 190 million individual consumers from more than 2600 merchants"; others compile what people report about themselves in "marketing surveys, warranty registrations, and contests."[1]
California's privacy agency gives everyday examples: "Grocery stores, clothing retailers, or other apps may collect your purchase history," and data brokers "often collect information from businesses you interact with directly."[3] When California's Attorney General warned businesses running loyalty programs in 2022, he said data is "collected when we enter our phone number for a discount at the supermarket," and that California law requires a "notice of financial incentive" explaining the terms before you join.[6]
Online activity counts too. Some brokers in the FTC study crawled social media profiles that were not set to restrict access, and at least one obtained "web browsing activities from online advertising networks."[1]
How do apps pass on my location?
FTC cases show three routes:
- Code inside apps. According to the FTC, X-Mode/Outlogic collected precise location data "from third-party apps that incorporate its software development kit (SDK)," from its own apps, and "by purchasing location data from other data brokers and aggregators," then sold it to "hundreds of clients."[7]
- Ad auctions. When an app shows an ad, information about the device goes out in a bid request. The FTC alleged that Mobilewalla "collected data from real-time bidding exchanges and third-party aggregators," kept bid-request data "even when it didn't have a winning bid," and collected more than 500 million advertising identifiers between January 2018 and June 2020.[8]
- Resellers. The FTC alleged that Gravy Analytics and Venntel "obtained consumer location information from other data suppliers" and claimed to process more than 17 billion signals from around a billion devices a day.[9]
These descriptions are the FTC's allegations, from its announcements of orders against each company. The advertising identifier on your phone is one of the identifiers California's DROP lets you submit for deletion.[5]
Do data brokers buy from each other?
Yes. For the nine brokers the FTC studied, it was the main source: they "obtain most of their data from other data brokers rather than directly from an original source," and seven of the nine provided data to each other. One broker got consumers' contact information from twenty different sources.[1]
That chain is why one record can appear on many sites at once, and why a correction or removal at one broker doesn't reach the others.
How does my address end up on a people-search site?
The FTC says people-search sites may "buy information from other data brokers," "collect information from social media profiles that are public or viewable by everyone," and "compile data from federal, state, and local government public records."[10] Our article What Are People-Search Sites? explains these sites in more detail.
Can I find out where a broker got my data?
Often not. The FTC concluded it "would be virtually impossible for a consumer to determine how a data broker obtained his or her data," because "the consumer would have to retrace the path of data through a series of data brokers."[1]
If you live in California, you can ask a business that collects your personal information to tell you "the categories of sources from which the personal information is collected." That gives you categories, not a list of named suppliers.[12] California's Data Broker Registry also shows what kinds of data each registered broker says it collects.[13]
What can I do about it?
- Remove the public listings first. People-search sites are where your address is easiest to find. Start with How to Remove Your Address From the Internet.
- Use your state's privacy rights. See deletion rights by state for what your state's law allows, and the Do-it-yourself page to write a request.
- If you live in California, use DROP. It sends one free deletion request to "over 600 registered data brokers."[5]
- Ask marketing data brokers too. They don't publish a search page, but they hold purchase and interest data, so ask each one through the privacy contact on its own site.
- Feed them less. Check which apps can see your location, read a loyalty program's terms before you join, and keep social profiles visible only to people you choose.
Frequently asked questions
Do data brokers get my information from me?
Mostly not. In the FTC's study of nine data brokers, none collected data directly from consumers; they got it from government records, other public sources and businesses, and most of it from other data brokers.[1]
Can data brokers legally sell public records?
State privacy laws generally leave public records out. California and Virginia, for example, exclude information lawfully made available from government records from the personal information their laws protect.[4][11] This is a description of the laws, not legal advice.
Can I find out where a data broker got my information?
It is hard: the FTC found the data often passes through a chain of brokers. California residents can ask a business for the categories of sources it collected their information from.[1][12]
If a broker deletes my data, can it come back?
Yes. People-search brokers told the FTC that deleted information reappears when they refresh their data. California's DROP makes registered brokers re-check for new matching data at least every 45 days.[1][5]
Related guides
Or have jdelete send requests to 900+ data broker sites as your authorized agent.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission, Data Brokers: A Call for Transparency and Accountability (May 2014), pp. iv, 10–14, 34. https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/data-brokers-call-transparency-accountability-report-federal-trade-commission-may-2014/140527databrokerreport.pdf
- California Civil Code §1798.99.80(c) (Delete Act definition of "data broker"), via the public.law copy of the official code. https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_1798.99.80
- California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy), "Personal information and data brokers." https://privacy.ca.gov/drop/personal-information-and-data-brokers/
- California Civil Code §1798.140(v)(2) (CCPA, "publicly available" information), via public.law. https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_1798.140
- CalPrivacy, "Delete Request and Opt-out Platform (DROP)" and "How DROP works." https://privacy.ca.gov/drop/ and https://privacy.ca.gov/drop/how-drop-works/
- California Attorney General, "On Data Privacy Day, Attorney General Bonta Puts Businesses Operating Loyalty Programs on Notice…" (January 28, 2022). https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/data-privacy-day-attorney-general-bonta-puts-businesses-operating-loyalty
- FTC, "FTC Order Prohibits Data Broker X-Mode Social and Outlogic from Selling Sensitive Location Data" (January 9, 2024). https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/01/ftc-order-prohibits-data-broker-x-mode-social-outlogic-selling-sensitive-location-data
- FTC, "FTC Takes Action Against Mobilewalla for Collecting and Selling Sensitive Location Data" (December 3, 2024). https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/12/ftc-takes-action-against-mobilewalla-collecting-selling-sensitive-location-data
- FTC, "FTC Takes Action Against Gravy Analytics, Venntel for Unlawfully Selling Location Data Tracking Consumers to Sensitive Sites" (December 3, 2024). https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2024/12/ftc-takes-action-against-gravy-analytics-venntel-unlawfully-selling-location-data-tracking-consumers
- FTC Consumer Advice, "What To Know About People Search Sites That Sell Your Information" (July 2022). https://consumer.ftc.gov/articles/what-know-about-people-search-sites-sell-your-information
- Code of Virginia §59.1-575 (definitions of "personal data" and "publicly available information"). https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/59.1-575/
- California Civil Code §1798.110(a) (right to know), via public.law. https://california.public.law/codes/civil_code_section_1798.110
- CalPrivacy, California Data Broker Registry. https://cppa.ca.gov/data_broker_registry/